Kayak Pin Recovery, Lower-Lower White Salmon

Here is a YouTube video of a kayak-pin recovery I stopped to help with back in August.

Zach Collier suggested I post and invite comments. The decisions were made by their group and I helped where I could. After a few failed attempts at other strategies, this was ultimately successful. I won’t editorialize, but I will answer questions if there are any. The recovery starts at about 4:45. I’ll get the first question out of the way, the person swam well above the log and she was fine, boat floated down and pinned by itself.

1 Like

I was there for this little show and have many observations. Does anyone want to know anything in particular?

1 Like

I’m always curious about how leadership is established.

Also was downstream safety set and was there an upstream spotter. How were those roles filled?

Good questions. I would say that the most temperamentally bold of us just sort of took over and tried various, ineffective things for quite awhile until, after a long time, the one person with the most experience in rescue finally came forward and proposed a plan that actually worked. Some of this may also have been compounded by gender. The bold dudes, myself included, had what turned out to be failed ideas. The winning plan was proposed by a competent, but very quiet, lady. None of this really mattered as it was a warm day and the boatless boater was safe on shore. But it t could have been potentially disastrous if this dynamic had played out in a critical pin where someone’s life was at stake.

And while we did have someone downstream in a kayak to pick up the pieces this was no official upstream spotter. I am not sure there needed to be in this case as the whole scene was an unmistakable circus when viewed from upstream.

i’ll add a couple of observations. Agreed, the woman who pulled this off was courageous, skilled and very trusting of her rope handlers. She told me later that she felt stable as long as she was in the middle of the boat but had to move to the bow to clip the throw-bag and it started getting pretty squirrely. She did flip shortly after that segment of the video ended, fortunately away from the log and pinned boat and not into it. Some were thinking we should pull towards the right bank at that point but we decided to see if we could lift the bow out of the water a bit from the left and relieve some pressure and it came loose quickly that way.

1 Like

Looks great. Looks like you tried a few things that did not work out so well before you finally found the technique that worked.

My only observation is that so many young boaters are happy to invest in top of the line kit but they are not investing in good quality training from reputable instructors. There seemed to be lots of people stood around clueless of what to do with a pinned boat. My question is how would they have reacted if there was a person in the boat unconscious ?

1 Like

In that case somebody - perhaps even me - would have risked life and limb to get out on the sketchy log and get direct contact with the boat. We would have needed to do this in the first two minutes. All the standing around was partly due to the fact that there was no urgency to this situation.

Of course, an even better course of action might have been to tape an open caribiner to a paddle and use this to attach a rope to a hard point. Someone - perhaps not coincidentally another thoughtful lady - remembered this technique hours after the fact! This speaks, I think, to the need to rehearse emergency responses ahead of time and with some frequency so that they are second nature and available under pressure.

1 Like

As a boater who was present during the pin, there were a couple constructive points upon reflection I think are worth mentioning.

A large group size can be a hindrance in a rescue situation unless a clear incident commander is established. There were several groups of paddlers who weren’t all familiar with one another. At the end of the day everyone was trying to be polite while also trying to figure out the boat rescue. No one made any poor decisions by any means to put paddlers in further danger.

It was a warm, sunny, and low water bottom lap with a wide variance of boating and rescue experience. With the swimmer safely on shore and lots of upstream and downstream paddlers in their boats, there was no real necessity to act quickly. After all, it’s just gear. As a result I think those with rescue experience didn’t speak up when a plan was already in motion.

My partner (the woman who suggested the tethered boat rescue) and I both have extensive rescue training and experience both in the States and abroad. We both at one point or another suggested alternate methods to unpin the boat over the initial attempts. Because there were no clear leaders these suggestions were either dismissed or not heard (to no fault of anyone else there, it was a natural cadence to the situation at hand given the group size, lack of urgency, and general unfamiliarity of all boaters present).

Had there been a live body either in or out of their boat in immediate danger, those with rescue experience would have undoubtedly spoken up immediately and taken control of the situation.

I believe a swift water rescue course, even at its basest level, is an incredibly valuable tool for anyone paddling class III or above. An important tenet of rescue training is to establish a clear leader to control the direction of action and information in these circumstances.

In retrospect I think it would have been valuable to ask all members in the group the extent of their rescue experience and pick an incident commander from that point to direct the flow and plan of action.

As someone who was very familiar with the concept and implementation of tethered boat rescues, Jessica was very comfortable with the duckey lower and bail out plan in case the boat flipped (which it ultimately did).

We’re all growing out there and I think it was a good learning experience!

3 Likes

Here is a bit of commentary from our live show last week

2 Likes